Looks can be deceiving. This looks like a barbeque restaurant on a typical street corner, anywhere, U.S.A. As I was capturing the brackets I was also thinking that Judy and I would pay a visit to Lucille’s afterwards (we enjoy their ribs and chicken). After I captured the brackets for this image we moved down the street (on the sidewalk that is off the left edge of this image) where, after capturing some more brackets I was accosted by a security guard. It was then that I learned this was not a typical street corner in the United States (at least not yet being typical).
This branch of Lucille’s is located at the “out door shopping mall” known as Victoria Gardens in Rancho Cucamonga, California. The security guard who is apparently employed (either directly or through a subsidiary) by Forest City who developed and manages the venue, was telling me what I may and what I may not photograph at the venue from my vantage point on the sidewalk. I tried to use the rationale that I was on a public sidewalk, and thus could photograph anything I wanted, it was then that I was informed that I was on private property. I was told that I may photograph my companion for a “snapshot” but that I was not permitted to photograph anything or anyone else on the property. This just did not sit very well with me and I was getting quite worked up about it, but Judy more or less dragged me away, packed me in the van and we left the venue.
Not happy with how all that went I then did some research with the city of Rancho Cucamonga and learned that the streets and sidewalks that comprise Victoria Gardens, although inter-connected to the surrounding public streets and public sidewalks, and even though not equipped with any physical barriers or other restriction to access, are still private property and there is no implied or mandatory public easement. So despite the fact that the venue looks like just another commercial district within a given municipality, with streets, sidewalks, blocks of free standing commercial structures and adjacent parking lots (including “street parking”) this is not a typical American neighborhood and the “rules” are quite different from my own, home neighborhood.
Still unhappy about this apparent “policy” of the property managers I sent the following email to Forest City this past January 13:
You really should reconsider one of your policies that impacts guests on your premises.
I was made to feel very unwelcome at Victoria Gardens this past Tuesday evening. I was sitting (in my power chair, I am disabled) on one side of a street on your property, photographing a business across the street (the building was replicating early to mid 20th century architecture, and they had a retro-looking neon light that had caught my eye). I was approached by a security person (who maintained his professionalism throughout the entire contact) who told me I could take a personal photograph of my wife standing in front of the building, but that I was not permitted to take any pictures that did not have someone I knew in them.
You can’t call a policy like that as being about homeland security, it is all about a commercial enterprise claiming the right to control use of their image, whether the image captured identifies the owning entity or not, no matter what the context of the image captured might be. I understand that a commercial enterprise has the right to protect its assets, but one of the primary assets of a shopping mall is the good will of the public who would chose to do business with you. It is ironic that as the developers and management of this property you do everything you can think of to entice the public to visit your facility, which includes public spaces that encourage lingering, and then you run off a member of the public who has responded to your efforts.
As noted previously, the security officer behaved professionally and I commend him for his patience and professional handling of the situation. When I challenged his authority to restrict my photography on a “public street” he confirmed with his supervisor that we were on private property, as the street is your property, which may be true but I am wondering what implications, if any, there are surrounding an easement for the passage of the public through the property. I knew then that your company was asserting its rights, but It still did not sit very well with me and I informed him that he should tell his management that I had previously been happy shopping and dining on the property and probably would have done so again in the future, but that youe company’s asinine policy had changed all that.
Sometimes a corporation’s right to totally control how their assets are used should be tempered with some common sense and human kindness. What was lost on the conscience of your company was that this all started out because I enjoyed the ambiance of your venue and wanted to capture a small fragment of that to share with others. Now you have gone and spoiled that.
I also emailed a general inquiry about photography policies to about a half dozen other specific venues or management companies, trying to ascertain if I would be welcome to capture photographic images and use a tripod. One responded no, altogether on all of their managed properties, one responded with some restriction and the others have not responded. In contrast to all of this, The Huntington, in San Marino, California, where I have captured images before, actually has a very welcoming and reasonable photography policy.
To date, my email to Forest City has not been responded to. I can only surmise that Forest City, if they know I exist at all, they perceive me as just a pesky gnat, and I have no impact on their bottom line. I also know that I could have handled myself differently, and I know from reading other photographers’ postings that probably the best course of action in these circumstances is to try and get your shots unnoticed in these quasi-public venues, and if noticed, be gracious and don’t “rock the boat”, which will be my tactic in the future.
Having recounted all of the above, it still does not sit well with me at all, that corporations do have so much power over the public, that they might, through their asset holdings capture more power and influence over us as individual Americans. The Supreme Court decision last year that essentially gave corporations rights equal to the rights given to individual human citizens could actually portend the beginning of the end of freedom and liberty for American citizens.
I will carry on with my life, and while I may never choose to visit Victoria Gardens ever again, I will continue to enjoy the beef ribs and chicken at the Lucille’s Barbeque in Chino, California, where I won’t be accosted if I am using my camera outside.
A typical Thursday evening on I-210 in southern California, something that many of us have had to face for decades on end. I am happy to say that I made it through the grinder for about 40 years and now do not have to submit to it, unless I choose. I was in the power chair in the van, positioned just behind the front seats, happily snapping away, while Judy was at the wheel, toughing it out for the trip home.
It was the first time I used my new AF-S Nikkor 28-300mm f/3.5-5.6 G ED-VR since I had acquired it. As we were rolling through stop-and-go traffic on the freeway I realized that we were missing the Golden Hour lights and shadows expressed across the San Gabriel Mountain Range which parallels I-210. I pulled the camera out of the bag and mounted the big lens and began snapping away, at the distant mountains, and at the cars on the freeway. The light was fading fast, and the jerky traffic movements were not helping me get my shots, this was the best of the lot.
I have a feeling I am going to enjoy using this lens more.
This image looking through the barrel vaulted lobby area of the Pasadena City Hall was captured the same evening as the image in my previous post. Prior to making the image above, I had been positioned about midway between the foreground and the archway you see from this vantage point, facing in the opposite direction as this. I was trying to capture a similar archway with pediments that was framing the atrium beyond. The image that I captured in that attempt, when rendered on the LCD on the back of the camera was not as successful as I had hoped, it was then that I moved forward (toward the back arch I had been targeting) and turned around that I realized the better composition was the image that presented itself behind me.
In this scene we are looking through the barrel vaulted, tiled outdoor lobby area of the city hall, looking west in to the evening sky just after sundown. This is a very interesting location for photography, for some reason this image seems very film noir-ish to me, making me think of the movie “Chinatown” that starred Jack Nicholson, Faye Dunaway and John Huston. You sort of wonder who will step out from the shadows next to the building columns.
This and the previous image captured at this location have, in my opinion, been my best HDR images created to date.
The weather in Southern California has been unusually cool recently and when we came upon Starbucks last Saturday evening every available seat inside was taken up with bodies staying nice and toasty. The temperature outside was probably in the low forties or high thirties when this image was captured, making the very hot, large non-fat mocha latte that Judy brought out to me that much better.
The exposures were 1/20, 1/6 and .7 second, using the monopod. A couple of hot spots were dodged, and one area was cooled down using Control Points in HDR Efex Pro and Nik Sharpener Pro 3 was used for final sharpening.
Victoria’s Secret anchoring (or providing the foundation for) the stores at the corner of Main Street and City Center Drive at The Shoppes, Chino Hills, California. Killing some time while waiting, and then deciding not to take in a movie, we took a few shots of the stores, people and decorative lighting at The Shoppes at Chino Hills, which is the baby brother of Victoria Gardens in Rancho Cucamonga. There is more to see and photograph at Victoria Gardens, but neither of us was feeling like a 20 minute drive to get there.
A tripod was not used, instead all images were captured using my new monopod. Tripod legs always interfere with the power chair, and if using a tripod I can’t get myself close enough to the camera mounted on the tripod to see through the view finder, the monopod fits between my knees, right in front of the chair. Exposure times were 1/8, .7 and 3 seconds for this HDR image. Look closely and you will see a hint of ghosting on the street right in front of Victoria’s Secret, a car was passing through the T-intersection. I did try to out wait the motor vehicles passing by, and the pedestrians to avoid as much ghosting as possible.
As noted above, Nik HDR Efex Pro was used for the HDR processing and tone mapping, exposure and contrast adjustments were made using the Nik Control Point tool in selected areas of the image (sky, palm trees, Victoria store front, various other store facades).
Judy and I were out scouting possible photo locations at dusk yesterday and came across the Euclid Stockyard in Chino, California, the parking lot empty except for the eighteen wheeler parked in front of the auction shed, its engine idling. Despite the seeming wall to wall housing tracts, shopping centers and warehouse/distribution centers proliferating in the local area, there is still enough of a dairy industry and horse farms to sustain the stockyard. But for how much longer is debatable, and the scene last evening probably portends the sunset of this type of life in our local area as occurring sooner, rather than later.
Today’s post showcases images of the more contemporary Vette’s on display last week-end:
“The Eye Catcher”
“The Money Pit”
All images were captured hand-held, no effort was made to eliminate the ghosting of the people in the frames. Exposure, color brightness and saturation and contrast were manipulated using Lightroom 3, and NIK’s: Color Exfex Pro and Silver Efex Pro. Noise reduction, sharpening and HDR processing were accomplished with NIK’s Dfine, Sharpening Pro and HDR Efex Pro.
After looking at more photographers’ examples of HDR in their portfolios and viewing some more tutorials I tried out some more of my newly acquired skills and got some more practice bringing it all together.
These images were all captured at Paseo Pasadena, Pasadena, California. Judy likes the building across the street, I do to, and I like the palm tree motif in the fence playing against the real palm trees behind it. My goal in this picture and the next was to express a strong “architectural” feeling.
The tone mapping is a bit more intense on this one, which captures the west end of Paseo Pasadena I like the differences in textures between the glass, bricks and pavers, and still going for an “architectural rendering” style.
All of the photos were brought over to the computer from the camera as Nikon NEF raw files, converted to DNG raw files, HDR processed, tone mapped, then raw processed again and adjusted, then one of them was corrected for perspective and cropped.
The first two images were shot at approximately 6:00 P.M. in early September, the last of the Archlight Cinema was shot on the same day at approximately 7:45 P.M. All were from hand held positions (in the wheel chair, which helped keep me steady). The blurred image in front of the kiosk in the foreground is people moving, I did not try “freezing” any images of the people, my primary interest was to capture the colors and texture of the scene, and I wanted to deliberately let some of the people move during exposure to create an idea of movement.